Katy Schutte
  • Home
  • VIDEO
  • About
  • Workshops
  • Corporate
  • The Improviser's Way
  • Blog
  • Contact

The Improviser's Way

A blog for improvisers
subscribe

​Sanity to Longevity: Improv’s Struggle with Playing Live Online

20/4/2020

13 Comments

 
We have an art form whose tenets boast comfort with failure. Are any of us comfortable with this failure?
 
The history of pure improvisation on TV and film is almost non-existent. We have game shows and panel shows with producers live-directing the cast and much written stand-up material stuffed in where possible. Anything good that comes out of improvisation on TV or film is because of the edit. Our best examples are assisted by heavily structured storylines with alternate takes, edited into their best possible shape afterwards (e.g. Paul Feig). We have characters immersing themselves in a world where a puppet-master introduces elements for them to react off of (e.g. Mike Leigh). We have real life and emulated real life where people are aware of the cameras (documentaries/reality shows and the mockumentary style made famous by Christopher Guest). But when something is edited, it is not live improvisation. It’s writing.
 
So why are we trying so hard to make improvisation work online – and can it?
 
In these lockdown times, improvisers have thrown themselves into different camps. There are those who have switched off and avoided; feeling fear or even a sort of betrayal in learning, teaching or performing online. Then there are those whose identities are challenged by not being able to improvise live: their solution is to double-down and reinvent, imagining themselves noble where perhaps the reality is anxiety or a necessary desperation for income. I have visited both camps. For the first few weeks I felt a huge sense of overwhelm, that I should, that I was a bad person for not, that I was doing it anyway and was that unfair because I didn’t believe in it?
 
After the first flush, the sorting hat of post-live improv gave us clearer factions, spilled out around the community, some preaching, some struggling. Unsurprisingly, it was the strong-willed A-type coming to the fore. I will teach you how to do this new thing (that I am also just learning myself). Those comfortable with the technology are leading the blind like gurus, fake-it-till-you-make-it-ing and saying it is a kindness.
 
I’m a science fiction fan, so this all seems very familiar to me. I’ve lived my life with a few extra food cans in a corner cupboard; on every flight, I say Thank the Gods to myself as I imagine telling my grandchildren about the Sky Birds that used to take us to distant lands. None of this feels like a surprise, though there are very few of us – including me - who planned ahead to a time when we can’t play an actual physical improv game with actual physical contact.
 
In the beginning, then, we used online improv for sanity. In our Maydays drop-ins, one of our check points for a class was to reassure everyone that they may feel strange or sad and that’s okay. Our only connection as a species was found online and therefore any improv, any conversation or silly game was enough, it kept the Black Dog from the door. Everyone is in a different state of course, this is harder for some than others for reasons we all understand.
 
Normality was the next phase, finding something that was routine. Waiting for your favourite improv school to put on a drop-in class so that you can go along like it’s a normal Tuesday. Then a jam night or – Blessed Be! – a course. I find myself going into a week with four nights of teaching, a show or two and a podcast recording. Apart from living through a pandemic, life is familiar. But what happened to the Dark Night of the Soul? What about that bit where I cried with my whole body at the breakfast table in front of my husband, wondering how I would be able to stay independent and who I even was if I wasn’t an artist and a teacher. Wasn’t there a reason for that?
 
Are we just normalising our regular schtick and expecting it to work in this new medium? We smile and congratulate ourselves for doing a show or class in ‘difficult circumstances’ with all the compromises that come with two dimensions, an invisible, inaudible audience and semi-pro equipment, using an art form that hasn’t worked longform on screen… ever? I worry that we’re doing it for us and not for an audience (and perhaps that’s fine). I’ve played in a couple of passable shows and a delightful one or two, but I don’t know what they were like for the audiences. I’ve not watched them back and I haven’t been able to sit through a single full show made by any improv group. Sometimes I’ll watch the first 5-10 minutes and think ‘well done, that basically works’ and be able to take a trick or too back to the cave. Lots of my colleagues and friends have ideas (and blogs) about what works or what doesn’t work, what is or isn’t a good show or form or framing or set-up, but not that many people are asking why.
 
Longevity is the thing that most of us don’t seem to be comfortable looking at. Yes – we have no deadline and that’s the hardest thing of all. Perhaps if we knew it was six weeks; we’d all try and take an actual break or just tidy the house and read, but because we don’t know how sustainable we have to be or how long our money will last, we are in the dark.
 
What happens after?
 
For my part, I’ve been teaching writing, which I don’t think loses anything from being online. This isn’t a sales pitch, because they all sold out. It’s a humble-brag, then; but one that’s here to underline the point. After… all this; I’ll still be able to do that course and it will be a good one and people will still join from all over the world. But that’s not improv. Will anyone still be going to online drop-ins after the fact? No. It may be a tool for teams spread around the world, it can be an in for people who simply cannot join a live class, but I don’t think it will sustain.
 
My open question, then is how are we spending our time and why are we doing it that way? Let’s think of things that will last; what improv show would be better online than on stage. Can we admit that podcasting* has already totally nailed it for years? What can we do with screens and text and screen-sharing that we can’t do on stage? I don’t know, I’m an amoeba right now, but I’m pretty sure no one has cracked it because Netflix. I am the biggest fan of good improv, but if it’s a wrinkly green screen and that fucking space virtual background, I’m going to watch Better Call Saul.
 
What I have enjoyed are shows that take mine and your suggestions the moment we tune in, absentmindedly, half way through; I can hang out for five minutes before I’m distracted by something else. Shows that ask us to buy a ticket (from a finite number of tickets) because when we invest any amount of money, we put the show in our diaries and we stay for the duration so that our money went somewhere. Shows that then delete the show. Give me FOMO. Make me feel like I missed out and I must be there next time.
 
The advantages are; where we are in the world doesn’t matter. I can play with and teach anyone from anywhere and that’s awesome, even if it is at 3am. There is a limit to who can go to improv festivals because they’re expensive to attend, they may not be accessible to everyone and there are people who are committed to family holidays. This crisis levels the playing field a bit. There is a coming together – we are sharing information as we discover it. All the Zoom calls between improv practitioners, the lists of Facebook interrogations into the situation and the many blogs.
 
Let’s move from sanity to longevity.

*My friend Lloydie's thoughts in a great blog on podcasting in these times.
13 Comments
BOC link
21/4/2020 07:34:05

I think about this literally every day. I don’t like any of my answers so far.

Christopher Guest.

Thank you for this.

Reply
Margot Escott link
21/4/2020 17:20:04

Wonderful piece expressing my thoughts as well.The greatest joy I have these days is attending great classes online and teaching. Thank you for such a well-written piece.

Reply
Eva Gilliam
21/4/2020 20:00:33

Here here! Nailed it, too.

Reply
Dan Wilson link
21/4/2020 22:18:35

Yes, yes, yes. I have had several discussions about this, and the best experience I have yet had was with a reunion of my old improv podcasting project. Yep. That show was edited improv. I cut whatever didn’t work, or even if it just threw the pacing off.
Everyone was comfortable playing to the mic and damn it felt good.

And I still wouldn’t put it out as an unfiltered project. To use the old maxim: the medium is the message. Zoom is not a stage. It is something different, and I remain unconvinced that we can replicate our little black box shows to that compressed medium.

Reply
Douglas Eaton-Landis
22/4/2020 15:16:36

Your exploration of our motivations for performing/watching improve online is both insightful and painful. I don't think the pain was meant in a cruel or punitive way. In fact, it was kind of cathartic. I've had doubts about the performances I've seen online recently, and I've found a growing sense of guilt inside me because I'm not enjoying what I'm seeing. Even the well-seasoned troupes and intuitive professionals are struggling through some very excruciating improv. The medium of Zoom, in the land of Facebook Live, Instagram Live, Twitch and others has drained the human connection from cooperative performance and the audience who endures it like they're donating blood. My heart goes out to all who have selflessly performed shows online with the deafening silence of an audience who cannot feedback to the performers. I miss all of you in the living breathing flesh, and lament my weakness in not being able to appreciate damn good improvisers, unless they're performing in the same room as I am.
Maybe now is the right time to explore solo, improvised storytelling. One face on a screen, making up a story with performed dialogue and active suggestions from the audience. Its a possibility that minimizes the shortcomings of the medium. Of course, its always possible that I'm just stuck in the past, and can't adapt to the new technology. Quite possible, actually.
Peace y'all.

Reply
Donna Paul
22/4/2020 19:59:37

Thanks for the article. At this time I have watched a lot of improv shows online. The one I remember the most was the Call Centre
From the May Days ....
The positive side of all of this is observing all the creativity and willingness to adjust adapt and accept the new possibilities and let go of what does not work in this medium ....
Quite a challenge...
I have really enjoyed meeting people from around the world. Getting up at 3 am to play. Was worth it a few times at least...
Sleep being so messed up I completely lost a day last week...
Anyway thanks and I look forward to meeting you on Monday !

Reply
susan
18/3/2022 01:20:04

I WANT TO USE THIS OPPORTUNITY TO THANK THE GREAT SPELL HEALER DR ORIANE FOR HELPING TO CURE ME OF FIBROID AFTER A LONG 3 YEARS FIGHT WITH, HIS HERBS ARE REALLY RELIABLE.
I can not believe up to this moment because it was a magic. A great testimony that I have to share with all those having FIBROID problem in the world. I never thought that the treatment could be complete without surgery, I saw the testimony of people on blog sites and on the Facebook page of how Dr. ORIANE is preparing herbal healing. different kind of the disease, and with the help of his herb they were able to shrink their fibroid naturally. I had to try it too and you can not believe that in just a few weeks I started using it, but all my pain stopped gradually. At this moment, I want to tell everyone that I just had a baby last month and that now that I'm thin, I do not I felt worse and went to get a message last week and the doctor confirmed that there was no trace of any fibroid s in my system. Glory to God for leading me to this great Dr. ORIANE. I am so happy to share this testimony. My advice to anyone who thinks there is no herbal remedy for fibroid s is wrong, just contact him for a cure for his email (droriane6@gmail.com). or Whats App him via +2349031652461 and you will be free and free forever, try it and you will not regret it because it really works. I hope to see your testimony soon.

Reply
MONISHA ALEXIS
1/4/2022 11:55:12

I promise to share this testimony all over the world once my boyfriend returns to me, and today with all due respect I want to thank DR.ONIHA for bringing joy and happiness to my relationship and my family. I want to inform you all that there is a spell caster that is real and genuine. I never believed in any of these things until I lost my boyfriend, I required help until I found a great spell caster, And he cast a love spell for me, and he assured me that I will get my boyfriend back in two days after the spell has been cast. Three days later, my phone rang, and so shockingly, it was my boyfriend who has not called me for the past 6 years now, and made an apology for the heartbreak, and told me that he is ready to be my backbone till the rest of his life with me. DR.ONIHA released him to let me know how much I loved and wanted him. And opened his eyes to picture how much we have shared together. As I`m writing this testimony right now I`m the happiest girl on earth and me and my boyfriend are living a happy life and our love is now stronger than how it was even before our break up. So that`s why I promised to share my testimony all over the universe. All thanks goes to DR.ONIHA for the excessive work that he has done for me. Below is the email address in any situation you are undergoing, it may be a heartbreak, and I assure you that as he has done mine for me, he will definitely help you too.
EMAIL: ONIHASPELLTEMPLE@GMAIL.COM
CALL/WHATSAPP : +16692213962.
Website: http://onihaspells.com.

Reply
Norman Wendy
5/4/2022 07:12:43

I want to say a very big thanks to PRIEST JUMBA for the wonderful work he did for me in helping me to save my marriage, my husband ask for a divorce letter because of the little misunderstanding we had in the past few month, And i never wanted this because i love my husband so much and all our investment was a joint business and i don't want to be far away from my family and my two lovely kids. My friend told me about PRIEST JUMBA and how he also helped her with her marital issues, so i had to contact him because i want to stop my husband from completing the divorce letter and i want to keep my family together and after contacting him, i was told what i needed to do and when i was going to start seeing the result, I did as PRIEST JUMBA has instructed and after 3 days my Husband call me and start asking for my forgiveness and it was all like a dream to me and we are all living happily together again all thanks to PRIEST JUMBA . Contact Him today for marital help Email: Wiccalovespelltools@gmail.com ...OR VIEW HIS website : https://drjumbaspellhome.wordpress.com
youtube : https://youtu.be/kBvs5nQcjWo
facebook : https://www.facebook.com/Wicca-spell-tools-102869698481356

Reply
ashley kline
6/4/2022 02:34:08

I live in USA, I have to give this miraculous testimony, which is so unbelievable until now. I had a problem with my Ex husband 2 years ago, which lead to our break up. I was not myself again, i felt so empty inside me, my love and financial situation became worst, until a close friend of mine told me about a spell caster who helped her in the same problem too her name is Doctor Angelina. I emailed the spell caster and i told her my problem and i did what she asked of me, to cut the long story short. Before i knew what was happening , less than two days my husband gave me a call and told me that he was coming back to me i was so happy to have him back to me. The most interesting part of the story is that am pregnant. Thanks to Doctor Angelina for saving my marriage and for also saving others own too. Continue your good work Dr Angelina.. If you are interested to contact the great spell caster Email address: (angelicmama128@gmail.com )

Reply
Richard Wahl
11/4/2022 15:02:59

CONTACT THE BEST LOTTERY SPELL CASTER FOR THE RIGHT LOTTERY NUMBERS NOW HIS LOTTERY SPELL IS 100% GUARANTEE His websit obinnaspelltemple.com

Winner of $533 million Mega Millions jackpot Richard Wahl, I want to share my wonderful testimony of how a powerful spell caster called Dr Prince helped me to win lottery, i have been playing lottery for a long time now but I had no luck everything changed when I messaged Dr Prince about winning the lottery he assured me that I will be the next winner he told me what to do and I did it and 24 hours later he sent me the lottery numbers and I played it I couldn't believe it I won $533 million dollars it's was the best thing that have ever happened to me in my life. If you want to win a lottery WhatsApp or Call Dr Prince on this number +18144484537 or email him at obinnaspelltemple@yahoo.com His website https://obinnaspelltemple.com/

Reply
Robert Mitchell
15/4/2022 13:55:19

Am Robert Mitchell USA , How i purchased Willy Wonka Golden Ticket from Wal-Mart #2605 in Gallipolis and won $15,000, It still feels incredible that my life has changed and I thank Dr Prince  everyday for his help. It is the best feeling in the world knowing that I am financially secure.Dr.Prince has proved that all the comment that i have read about him are all true, I am saying this now because before i contacted Dr.Prince i was having doubts if all what i have read about Dr.Prince are true but after contacting him, i believed that Dr.Price  is truly powerful and his spell has the capability to Win all kinds of lottery All thanks Dr prince, his number +18144484537 This Man has been of immense blessing to me and my friends and i am putting his email here to help the world at large know about his abilities and power to solve various types of problems contact him today via obinnaspelltemple@yahoo.com

Reply



Leave a Reply.

    Buy the Book!

    Picture
    Enjoy my blog? Fancy buying me a cuppa to celebrate?

    RSS Feed

    There are many blogs! Search here for unlisted topics or contact me. 

    Author

    Katy Schutte is a London-based improviser who teaches improv classes and performs shows globally. 

    Recent Posts

    widget @ surfing-waves.com
  • Home
  • VIDEO
  • About
  • Workshops
  • Corporate
  • The Improviser's Way
  • Blog
  • Contact